By Darlin TilleryShareNewsweek is a Trust Project memberA Houston Airbnb host had their listing suspended for five days after a guest claimed the home was messy, despite the host providing video proof that the property was clean.
The host and original poster (OP), user Kristilacroixx, recounted the incident on Reddit, explaining that shortly after checking in, the guest—who they described as "the Guest From Hell"—lodged a complaint with Airbnb over a "mess."
"It’s been raining nonstop in Houston lately," they wrote. "I personally raked the backyard, but a few leaves fell during the downpour.
"That was their 'evidence'."
...Having filmed a detailed walkthrough before the guest arrived, the OP sent the high-definition video to Airbnb support after the complaint was filed.
But despite support staff reportedly acknowledging that the property appeared clean in the footage, the OP's listing was suspended for five days while the complaint was reviewed.
The guest allegedly went silent, refusing to engage with the OP.
'It's the principle'
"I’m actually okay because I was planning to block those days for maintenance anyway (installing a new breaker box and a larger fridge), but it’s the principle of it," the OP wrote.
"I have mountains of documentation, time-stamped video, and a solid track record, yet the platform still defaults to 'punish the host first, ask questions later.'"
The decision still left them frustrated, especially because the guest stopped responding after filing the complaint.
Reddit users and fellow hosts flocked to the comments to weigh in, with many slamming Airbnb and the guest's behavior.
One wrote, “If a guest claiming the house is messy enough not able to stay, lowkeyly say sorry and say you're ready to cancel their reservation and give them ‘firm’ time to vacate the listing ASAP and be kind in messages to offer them a refund.”
The OP replied, “Offering a firm time to vacate is the perfect ‘litmus test’ to see if they’re actually uncomfortable or just fishing for a free stay.”
Another user noted, “This happened to me last week. A guest checked in and immediately claimed the place was filthy,” adding that the guest demanded reimbursement for sheets, towels and cleaning supplies and asked for a 50 percent discount on a seven-day stay.
Airbnb Policies
Airbnb states that reviews and complaints must reflect genuine experiences and cannot be used to pressure hosts for refunds.
“Users may not threaten a negative review as a means to obtain unwarranted compensation, refund, or other incentive,” the company says in its review policy, according to the Airbnb Help Center.
This isn't the first time a dispute between hosts and guests has surfaced on social media.
In one dispute involving a Baltimore host, a judge criticized Airbnb’s handling of a complaint that led to the host’s account termination.
According to reporting published by Global Hosting Blogs, the judge said the company was “making money off this host, but not providing her due process or any real investigation."
Newsweek has reached out to Kristilacroixx and Airbnb for comment via Reddit. We could not verify the details of the case.
Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to help produce this story. Learn more about Martyn.Request Reprint & LicensingSubmit CorrectionView Editorial & AI Guidelines
Add Newsweek as a preferred source on Google to see more of our trusted coverage when you search.Related Podcasts
Top Stories
For MembersAnalysisUS School Strike Is Iran’s Most Powerful Weapon6 min read
For MembersAnalysis3 Warning Signs of a Hidden Financial Crisis7 min read
WorldDonald Trump Says ‘We Won’ Iran War5 min read
PoliticsSupreme Court Gets New ‘Emergency’ Petition from Trump Administration4 min read
PoliticsPete Hegseth Spent Millions on Steak, Crab Legs and Lobster: Report3 min read
For MembersAnalysisPam Bondi Moving Home Marks Dark Turn for US Politics7 min readTrending
Nancy GuthrieNancy Guthrie Sheriff Chris Nanos Hit With $1 Million Lawsuit4 min read
InternetDachshund and Corgi Have Puppy, Owner Shares Adorable Result3 min read
CaliforniaWarning Issued as 5 Million People Told to Stay Inside for 34 Hours3 min read
Trump Approval RatingDonald Trump’s Approval Rating Hits New Second-Term Low4 min read
snow stormHeavy Snow Warning As Up To 4 Feet To Hit: ‘Blizzard’4 min readOpinion
OpinionWhat the Critics Have Wrong About the Iran Conflict | Opinion4 min read
For MembersOpinionConventional Wisdom: Oil Shock Edition4 min read
OpinionThe War With Iran Is Reaching Places You Might Not Expect | Opinion7 min read
OpinionInternational Women’s Day: Leaders Warn Equality Is Stalling | Opinion6 min read
OpinionDemocrat Shutdowns Threaten Homeland Security Amid Heightened Threats | Opinion5 min read